New Construction

Custom Homes for Long Island Living

Center Island Contracting builds exceptional custom homes across Long Island. Our design-build team specializes in knock-down rebuilds that replace aging homes with modern, energy-efficient designs. Because developable land is limited on Long Island, starting fresh on an existing property often provides a smarter, more cost-effective solution than extensive additions or renovations.

We handle every stage of your project, from architectural design and permit management to construction and final walkthrough, so you can focus on the excitement of creating a home that is completely your own.

View Our Portfolio

A Clear Process for Building With Confidence

Why Build New on Long Island

Building new offers homeowners freedom, efficiency, and long-term value. When an existing home can no longer support your lifestyle or structural goals, demolition and rebuild can often be a better investment than remodeling.

Advantages of new construction:

Stay in your current community and school district while enjoying a completely new home.
Eliminate old mechanical systems and hidden structural issues.
Create open floor plans, natural lighting, and integrated smart-home features.
Reduce utility costs through ENERGY STAR® certified appliances, efficient HVAC systems, and advanced insulation.
Increase your home’s value and long-term durability.

If you are still considering your options, explore our Interior Renovations and Home Additions services to see which path best fits your needs.

Building & Renovating with Care

Unlimited Design Possibilities

Every home we build is unique.
Our process gives you full creative control through hands-on design experiences, expert guidance, and detailed visualization tools.

Immersive Design Experience

Private showroom and design center where you can see and compare materials in person.

Real-time 3D renderings and virtual walkthroughs that allow you to visualize your new home before construction begins.

Dedicated kitchen and bath designer on staff to help optimize layouts, storage, and finishes.

The ability to make real-time design modifications and preview results instantly.

Visit Our Showroom >

Personalized Floor Plans

Open-concept living areas that enhance light and flow.

Multi-generational suites designed for comfort and privacy.

Home offices and creative spaces tailored to your lifestyle.

Flexible bonus rooms that can evolve with your family’s needs.

View Our Process >

Premium Finishes and Features

Hand-selected cabinetry and millwork crafted through our private design center.

Natural stone countertops and backsplashes.

Smart home technology integration for security, lighting, and climate control.

Seamless indoor-outdoor living through custom patios and outdoor kitchens.

View Our Suppliers >

Sustainable and Stylish Elements

Reclaimed wood accents and eco-friendly materials sourced from trusted local suppliers.

Energy-efficient building envelopes that enhance comfort and reduce environmental impact.

Vaulted ceilings, clerestory windows, and architectural statement details that maximize natural light.

Meet Our Team >

Build Your Legacy in Your Ideal Location

Built to Last,
Designed to Love

Each Center Island Contracting home combines traditional craftsmanship with modern building science. We follow rigorous construction standards that exceed local building code requirements and promote long-term efficiency.

Superior Construction Standards
- Precision framing and advanced weatherproofing systems.
- High-performance insulation for consistent comfort in every season.
- Certified tradespeople supervised by experienced project managers.
- Thorough quality control inspections at every phase.
Energy Efficiency That Pays You Back
- Homes built to exceed New York State Energy Code requirements.
- ENERGY STAR® certified appliances, LED lighting, and smart thermostats.
- Advanced HVAC systems calibrated for performance and efficiency.
- Lower utility costs from the day you move in.

get inspired

One-Stop Solution That Eliminates Contractor Chaos

Our Proven Design-Build Process

Our process eliminates confusion and keeps your project on schedule. Each stage is managed by a single integrated team that handles architecture, permitting, construction, and finishing.

1
Discovery and Planning
We begin with a consultation to understand your goals, conduct a site analysis, and review zoning regulations.
2
Design Development and Visualization
Our in-house architects create floor plans, elevations, and 3D renderings. You can preview every room and select materials in our private showroom.
3
Foundation and Structure
Groundbreaking begins with expert excavation, foundation installation, framing, roofing, and weatherproofing.
4
Final Details
Final finishes, fixtures, and lighting are installed. A comprehensive inspection ensures every element meets our quality standards.
5
Welcome Home
We guide you through your completed home, provide system demonstrations, and deliver your two-year workmanship warranty.

gallery-new-construction-east-islip-2024-29-scaled

Delivering impeccable craftsmanship and exceptional results

Award-Winning General Contractor & Home Builder

Proudly recognized by Houzz, LIBI, and PRO New York for outstanding craftsmanship and service, our award-winning team continues to raise the bar in Long Island homebuilding.

Best of Houzz

Customer Service & Design

Recognized for Excellence in Service & Design

LIBI

Diamond Award

Whole-House Remodel, Kitchen Remodel, & Bath Remodel

PRO New York

Remodeler of the Year

Awarded for Exceptional Design & Construction

View More Center Island Contracting Awards & Recognition

Our Clients Share Their New Construction Experience

    
 
 
        
   HU-351188542 
 14 November 2024
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz. They do Beautiful work and Caleb is a straight forward guy. I highly recommend them for any job you may need done
  
 
       
   Toni Weiss 
 8 September 2024
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. We recently completed a nearly full remodel of our new home with Center Island Contracting, and we are absolutely thrilled with the results. Caleb, Evan, Bill, Myron, Raquel, Alicia, and every other team member were a pleasure to work with, and it was clear that our project was so much more than a job to them. In addition, the recommendations that they gave us for appliances, HVAC, closet customization, and painting exceeded our expectations for both pricing and job quality. We worked with several reputable companies while renovating our previous home, but I would unhesitatingly recommend CIC over all of them. It has been almost 3 months since we moved in, and we are still amazed at how precisely and impeccably CIC converted a vision in our minds into our dream home.
  
 
       
   Matthew Ferraro 
 7 November 2023
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Stumbled across CIC randomly searching contractors & so happy we did. Evan offered many options & worked with us to get our dream off the ground. Bill (their project manager)has positioned our job to be the best quality craftsmanship we could ask for & made us thrilled to work with them for one of  the most important decisions people can make in their lives. Improving our livelihood is an understatement! Many thanks to the entire team @ CIC.
  
 
       
   Maryann FP 
 10 March 2022
 
 
 recommendsTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Facebook. I had a vision and they made it come to life. A job well done by skilled friendly professionals, and the job was completed within the time they said it would.
  
 
       
   Ardian Haliti 
 28 January 2022
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. CIC team was a great pleasure to work with. Caleb, Mike, Myro and crew on site and office did a great job on my project and are highly recomended
  
 
       
   Neil Bailey 
 9 June 2021
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Very impressed so far with this company.  Extrermely responsive and willing to answer all of our queries.  We will decide shortly if we will decide to choose this company to design, manage and build our 2 floor house extension.
  
 
       
   Rosemarie Reyes Mecker 
 21 April 2021
 
 
 recommendsTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Facebook. They are reliable and do quality work and completes the job on target.
  
 
       
   sansone1 
 12 April 2021
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz. Caleb is wonderful to work with. He is knowledgeable and will point you in the right direction. He listens to your ideas and what you need. And helps as much as you want. He also stays on top of the job, Which is helpful when you have three kids and are designing a new space. But what I love the most is he is HONEST! The company is as professional as can be.
  
 
       
   dena3003 
 15 March 2021
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz. Caleb, Evan and the team at Center Island Contracting have done remarkable work on our home. They are honest, professional and have extraordinary talent. Their showroom is filled with countless designer options and I have truly enjoyed my experiences with them.
  
 
       
   Christina Valenzisi-Hadzovic 
 4 August 2020
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Caleb and his team were amazing! We used them for my parents home and couldn’t be happier with the work that was performed. We look forward to using them for our next project! Thanks again.
  
 
       
   Adam Ansanelli 
 4 February 2020
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. CIC does fantastic work. They should be your first call if you’re looking for quality high-end construction and finishing. Their online showroom speaks volumes on what they can do.
  
 
       
   William Cohen 
 16 May 2019
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. It is such a pleasure working with Center Island!  Caleb and Evan have incredible passion for their projects and run a very well-managed operation. I have collaborated with them on numerous projects and I highly recommend anyone looking for a different kind of experience when building or renovating their home.
  
 
       
   Marsha Lewitas 
 15 March 2019
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Very professional and detail oriented. Anxious to make customer pleased from planning to completion.
  
 
       
   Dean Miller 
 11 December 2018
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz. Caleb and his team were absolutely fantastic to work with. From the estimate process, to the start and finish of the job, and the follow up after completion, everything went exactly as planned. No headaches, on time, and very well done. I will definitely use Center Island again and will highly recommend them.

Transform Your Vision Into Your Forever Home

Experience the Center Island Contracting Difference

Advanced Design Technology

View your new home through photorealistic 3D renderings and virtual walkthroughs.
Preview materials and finishes in our private Design Center.
Make design changes instantly during collaborative sessions.

Expert Design Team

Work directly with our in-house architects and kitchen and bath designer.
Receive personalized guidance from licensed project managers.
Enjoy transparent communication through our online project management portal.

Proven Track Record

Over two decades of experience in custom home building across Long Island.
Licensed, insured, and locally owned with OSHA-compliant job sites.
Members of the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), National
Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI), National Kitchen & Bath
Association (NKBA), Long Island Builders Institute (LIBI), and PRO New York.
Honored with the PRO New York Remodeler of the Year (Platinum) and Best of Houzz for Service and Design awards.

gallery-new-construction-sag-harbor-2025-42

Professional Design-Build Services Across Long Island

Transform Your Vision into Your Dream Home

Benefit from our experience in project management, construction, and superior craftsmanship.

Schedule A Consultation

Understand Our Process

View Our Portfolio

View Our Pricing Guides

About New Home Construction

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Center Island Contracting differ from other home builders on Long Island?

Honestly? Most contractors can hang sheetrock and frame walls. What separates us is what happens before we ever show up on site.

We've spent years perfecting our preconstruction process - the planning, coordination, and problem-solving that needs to happen so your project runs smoothly once construction starts. That means fewer surprises, less time with workers in your house, and way fewer "we need to talk about this" moments in the field.

Because we handle both design and construction, there's no finger-pointing between architect and builder. One team, one process, complete accountability.

We also specialize in Long Island home styles - Capes, split-levels, ranches - so we know exactly how to work with what you've got. And we approach every project with an eye toward unlocking value in your home, not just adding square footage.

The result? Design-forward work that looks unique, executed with a level of precision that comes from doing this over and over until we got it right.

What types of new homes in New York can Center Island Contracting build?

We specialize in custom home construction and remodeling across Long Island, designing and building projects that range from modern contemporary to traditional styles. Our team has experience creating everything from cozy family homes to luxury estates. Unlike production builders who offer limited floor plans, we create truly custom designs tailored to your specific needs, preferences, and property characteristics.

How long does it typically take to build a custom home?

The honest answer? It depends on what you're building and how long your town takes to approve permits.

Most projects run 8-18 months from design to completion, but that range is wide for a reason. A second-story addition is different from a kitchen renovation, and some municipalities move faster than others.

Here's where our design-build approach helps: We don't wait for design to be 100% done before we start planning construction. We overlap those phases, which cuts weeks or even months off your timeline compared to the traditional architect-then-contractor approach.

We'll give you a realistic timeline once we understand your specific project and what approvals you'll need. And we keep you in the loop throughout - if something's running ahead or behind schedule, you'll know why and what it means for your completion date.

No surprises, no vague "it'll be done when it's done." Just honest communication from start to finish.

Can you handle both new construction and home renovation projects?

Yes - and honestly, doing both makes us better at each.

Our remodeling experience gives us a huge advantage when we're building new custom homes. We've heard every complaint homeowners have about their existing houses, and we've spent years fixing those problems. So when we design a new home from scratch, we're already incorporating solutions to issues most builders don't even think about until the homeowner asks for changes.

And when we're renovating? We approach it with the precision and planning of new construction. We're not just "making it work" - we're reimagining your space the way it should have been built in the first place.

Whether you're building new on an empty lot or transforming your existing home, you get the same systematic process, the same attention to detail, and the same design-build advantages.

The work might look different, but the approach is the same: methodical, value-focused, and built to last.

What sets your craftsmanship apart in new construction homes for sale?

Our craftsmanship is defined by attention to detail at every level of construction. From precision framing and advanced weatherproofing to custom millwork and fine finishes, we maintain exacting standards throughout the building process. We employ skilled tradespeople, use premium materials, and implement rigorous quality control measures to ensure your home is built to last. This commitment to quality is why many clients come to us after being disappointed by the workmanship of other builders.

Do you help with finding and evaluating properties for new construction?

While we don't act as real estate agents, we can provide valuable insights when you're considering properties for your new home. Our team can assess potential building sites for construction feasibility, zoning restrictions, and other factors that might impact your project. This consultation can help you find your new home location with confidence, understanding what's possible on different properties before making a purchase decision.

What kind of warranty do you offer on new construction homes?

We stand behind every home we build with a comprehensive two-year workmanship warranty. This exceeds the industry standard one-year warranty offered by many custom home builders. We also facilitate manufacturer warranties on appliances, systems, and other components. Our post-construction support ensures any warranty issues are addressed promptly and professionally.

How do you help clients manage their budget during the construction process?

We price everything upfront - no "we'll figure it out as we go" surprises.

During planning, we develop detailed specs and allowances so you know exactly what's included in your project. Want to upgrade the countertops or add recessed lighting? We'll tell you what that costs before you commit, not after the work's already done.

We work on a fixed-price contract, which means the number we agree on is the number you pay - unless you decide to change something. And even then, our change order process is transparent. You see the cost, you approve it, then we proceed.

We'll also help you make smart trade-offs. Sometimes spending more in one area unlocks value elsewhere, and sometimes you can save money without anyone ever noticing the difference. Our job is to give you the information to make those decisions confidently.

Bottom line: You stay in control of your budget, and there are no surprises when the bill comes.

Business Facts

Service: Custom residential home construction.
Projects include site preparation and architectural coordination.
Construction work includes structural framing and mechanical system installation.
Interior finishing and occupancy approvals are included in the construction process.
Service coverage includes Long Island, Nassau County, and Suffolk County.
Client types served include homeowners, landlords, and property developers.
Delivery model: On-site residential construction services.

Read all Business Facts about Center Island Contracting