Interior Construction Contractor in Bellmore, NY

Reworking Bellmore Interiors Built for a Different Era

 

Bellmore's housing includes postwar Capes and ranches as well as split-level and bi-level homes with layouts designed for a different era. As an interior remodeling contractor in Bellmore, NY, Center Island Contracting helps homeowners open closed-off spaces, update aging systems, and manage design, permitting, and construction through one coordinated process.

Share Your Vision for Your Home

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Name*

Transforming Outdated Layouts Into Functional Spaces

An outdated interior is rarely just a finishes problem. Closed-off rooms, awkward additions, uneven floor levels, and aging mechanical systems can all influence how far a Bellmore renovation should go. Before developing an open-concept conversion or whole-home remodeling plan, Center Island Contracting studies the relationships between the layout, structure, plumbing, electrical work, and HVAC.

  • Is the wall between your kitchen and living room load-bearing in your 1950s Cape Cod, limiting how open the floor plan can actually become?
  • Does your high ranch's layout separate living spaces in a way that no longer matches how your household uses the home day to day?
  • Could previous plumbing or electrical work behind the walls affect the layout, finishes, or construction sequence once demolition begins?
  • Is your split-level's multi-level layout creating coordination challenges across several rooms being renovated at once?
  • Does your unfinished basement lack the moisture control and ceiling height needed for the bonus room you are picturing?

Every interior in Bellmore carries a different combination of these conditions depending on when the home was built and what has already been changed. Center Island Contracting evaluates the layout, structure, and systems together before defining the interior remodeling scope.

gallery-interior-renovations-massapequa-2024-42

Explore Interior Remodeling Projects Across Bellmore and Long Island

Center Island Contracting's interior remodeling portfolio includes open-concept conversions, load-bearing wall removal, basement remodeling, whole-home renovations, and projects that coordinate layout changes with electrical, plumbing, and HVAC upgrades.

gallery-interior-renovations-massapequa-2024-01
<span class="number-gallery">No. 5746</span><hr class="project-gallery-hr">SYOSSET INTERIOR RENOVATION
gallery-interior-renovations-babylon-2023-34
gallery-additions-extensions-syosset-2026-35

Homeowner Reviews and Project Experiences

Bellmore homeowners describe a process where layout decisions and mechanical system findings are explained clearly before construction begins, not discovered mid-project.

Google
Olivia Pryce profile picture
Olivia Pryce
22 October 2025
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
+10
Center Island Contracting renovated my home from a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom to a 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom. It was a massive undertaking but it was successfully completed. My house is unrecognizable from the original structure. My friends and family are always impressed by the outcome. My financing was done through a construction loan and the team was patient and provided whatever documents were required for me to secure the loan. Have a conversation with Center Island to explore your options. It’s worth a try. I love my house!
Google
Joshua T profile picture
Joshua T
24 April 2025
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
+0
I would gladly hire them again for a future construction project, and I can think of no higher compliment. For this project, they updated a bathroom and helped us add a new primary suite. Pictured is the updated bathroom. The job was finished on time with the permit, the work looks great, pricing was fair, and they stayed communicative and patient every step of the way.
Google
Kenny Campagna profile picture
Kenny Campagna
15 February 2025
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Recently finished up a large renovation project where we added a new addition to our house which included a new primary bedroom and bathroom. Definitely satisfied with our choice of Center Island Contracting. From the initial quote all the way to the finishing of the project, everything was laid out in detail and done accordingly. Through out the entire process everyone at Center Island answered any questions we had and explained everything they did. Any issues that came up during the renovation was explained thoroughly with multiple options presented to us. I highly recommend them and will be using them for any future renovations.
Google
CJ Redfern profile picture
CJ Redfern
31 October 2024
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We were told it would take about four weeks to gut renovate our existing bathroom, add a primary bath, and stain our floors. It took them five months. How did a four week job turn into a five month job?!? We had all of our selections picked out before the job started. We were ready to go. They kept making excuses (oh, no work the week of Thanksgiving and Christmas) okay, adding an extra two weeks to the timeline still doesn't explain how a "four week" job turned into a FIVE MONTH job!! (Hint: we'd watch on our doorbell camera, workers only showed up 1-2 days a week, so when you're only working on our house 1 day a week, of course it's going to take a lot longer). We moved out on 11/9/23 and moved back in the first week of March. Also, be careful with their "quote/proposal". A lot of our selections were left out of the proposal with the promise that we could add them in officially later on in the process, but surprise, adding our selections in later on = massive change orders. They were obviously keeping the proposal to the bare minimum to keep it as low as possible to get our business. The two stars I'm giving is because after five long months and doubling our budget, the final product was decently good, and we're happy with the final product.
Google
Robert Carucci profile picture
Robert Carucci
12 December 2023
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We can't thank Center Island Contracting enough or the beautiful job they did renovating our home. Everyone who was part of the project was professional and thorough. Evan listened to our ideas and made them even better with his vision and expertise. John handling the architecture and making the permit process on our end effortless. Bill, our project manager, patiently addressing all our questions and concerns, making sure everything got done as it should. Caleb coming through in the clutch with the line voltage thermostat and flag pole lighting. Louis, Louis, Myron (and his son), Chris, and the entire crew who put in all the hard work doing the build. Their skill is top-tier and the nicest people you will ever meet. We are so happy we went with CIC for our project and would absolutely recommend them.
Google
Adam Pearsall profile picture
Adam Pearsall
8 August 2023
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Center Island did an amazing job renovating my home and staying on schedule up until completion. The final project is beautiful and my family loves the new bedroom and bathroom!
Houzz
Rusmir Dzanko profile picture
Rusmir Dzanko
31 May 2023
Houzz star 1Houzz star 2Houzz star 3Houzz star 4Houzz star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz.
We did a first floor renovation that included our kitchen and built-in cabinetry around our fireplace. The quality of work is very good. There was not any major surprises or issues that came up during our process. We are extremely happy with how our kitchen and other cabinetry came in. Our project manager Bill was very responsive and quick to action any requests/questions or issues we were having. He was always a quick text or phone call away. I would definitely look at Central Island for future work.
Google
Blaze profile picture
Blaze
21 December 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Love this company! They are professional, talented, and reliable. I had a wonderful experience working with Center Island Contracting. Bill, Caleb, Myron and Nicole were so helpful and did a fantastic job on my master bath! I am delighted with the end result.
Google
Kristen Dorfman Jata profile picture
Kristen Dorfman Jata
13 October 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
This review is long overdue! CIC completed a major home renovation for our family over the course of ~6 months. The entire first floor of our -4000sqft home was gutted to the studs. We added a bathroom, removed walls, installed two steel beams, reworked a kitchen, and so much more. From the beginning, everyone at CIC was responsive, understanding, and above all proactive. It’s hard to see the big picture when you’re in the thick of it but Caleb is truly a mastermind behind the scenes. Every single day was, for the most part, orchestrated down to the most minute detail. There wasn’t a single day for literally months that there wasn’t a at least one CIC employee doing something to move the project along. A project of this size is stressful, there is no way around that but we knew at the end of the day this project would be done the right way. The guys at Center Island truly became family, the same crew showed up day after day. Big big shout out to Luis and Myron who were the kindest humans. We were so lucky to have them helping us. Honorable mention to Chris who brought the humor! We really loved all of the guys. My husband and I have recommended them to many of friends and would continue to do so. We are always happy to share our “success story” as so often you hear so many negative things. One other thing to note, our project spanned a time of economic instability. Prices were rising by the day and it was stressful worrying about what that would do to our project’s budget. Caleb and Evan were the utmost professionals walking us through this very difficult time, always leveling with us, always full disclosure, and always handled difficult conversations with tact. Thank you to CIC!
Houzz
HU-598288584 profile picture
HU-598288584
12 May 2022
Houzz star 1Houzz star 2Houzz star 3Houzz star 4Houzz star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz.
We recently completed a complete renovation of our entire first floor with Center Island. This work included a kitchen, bathroom, major structural work involving recessed steel beams, new floors windows and doors. We did our homework and interviewed several contractors before deciding on moving forward with Center Island. For us, it was a no brainer. Evan worked with us on the design and selections. The owner of the company was hands on and knew where our 7 month long project was at every phase. The team that came to the house…they showed up on time. They were all amazing to work with. As you can imagine renovating a home is stressful, but the Center Island team made it as smooth as possible. They set expectations. They listened and responded to our feedback and made things happen. We love the results. It was a long road to get the project done due to the scope, but I would select Center Island again. The main difference is that they are a company and not a crew in a work truck. They show up on time and do great work. They have actual plumbers, carpenters and electricians. They partner with really good subs (HVAC, counter tops , painters) who all seem to share the owner, Caleb, sense of attention to detail, client service and expertise.
Houzz
Ardian Haliti profile picture
Ardian Haliti
22 January 2022
Houzz star 1Houzz star 2Houzz star 3Houzz star 4Houzz star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz.
CIC worked on my renovation project which included whole 1st floor of my house. They were very professional, accommodating and well organized throughout the project. Their recommendations were on target and honest. Mike, Myro and all of installation team as well as their office team did a great job. Caleb himself showed at my house to discussed the project around the fire place that I had contracted with CIC and he recommended me not to pursue the project in the scope and design I wanted it, which I think was very honest when you considering that he was helping me avoid some mistakes and save money during the project and this says a lot about him and the company he leads.
Google
deirdre reilly profile picture
deirdre reilly
21 April 2021
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I work with Center Island Contracting for many of my Interior Design projects , they are always knowledgeable, professional and the quality of their work is a step above everyone else.. I know my projects are in excellent hands whenever I work with them.. I highly recommend Center Island Contracting .. The Reilly Design Group
Google
Neil Brodsky profile picture
Neil Brodsky
24 September 2020
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The best of the best! We used CENTER ISLAND CONTRACTING for a complete whole house renovation in 2019 and the results are fabulous. The project was extensive and renovated the house to the studs. Caleb Haniquet and Evan Lewitas and their team took care of everything. They have been attentive to all of our wishes for our home and I have recommended them to friends and colleagues.
Google
Robert Reese profile picture
Robert Reese
3 March 2020
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Center Island Contracting has done multiple projects for me over the years, roof, gutters, windows, interiors. The work has always been top quality, and completely professional. The organization is easy to work with, and I will continue to partner with them in the future!
Google
Nicole Kessler profile picture
Nicole Kessler
11 February 2020
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had the pleasure of working with Caleb and Evan of Center Island Contracting on a client of mine's home renovation. As an Interior Designer I am particular and put quality and value at the upmost. This team proved to me they they are not only professional but value their work and their clients, which shows in their quality of work. I will be happy to join forces with them again in the future.
Houzz
L B profile picture
L B
22 August 2019
Houzz star 1Houzz star 2Houzz star 3Houzz star 4Houzz star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Houzz.
All I can say is WOW!!!! I was very skeptical looking for a contractor online. I had just purchased a new home and was interested in doing an entire home renovation . The internet can be very tricky especially when it comes to pictures as well as reviews . As far as Center Island Contracting and Owner Caleb Haniquet what you see on his website is the exact attention to detail and work at my new home. Caleb has great vision and an eye on how to design a house and not just your basic kitchens and bathrooms , i'm talking about every room in the home down to the paint colors. What I like most about doing this project as it was not my first is the fact that attached to Center Island Contractiing headquarters is Distinctive Designs This is a one stop shop for all your kitchen cabinets,wood floor,stone etc etc. It makes it so much easier than going from store to store. I would highly recommend CIC and Caleb to anyone who is doing any kind of renovation in their home. This is definitely not your Home Depot construction company that I can say so if you're looking for great product as well as when someone walks into your home and they say OH MY GOD... Then go with CIC as they're second to none...

PRO New York Remodeler of the Year Awards

Center Island Contracting received three awards at the PRO New York Remodeler of the Year Awards Gala Gold for Residential Kitchen, Platinum for Residential Exterior, and Platinum for Entire House renovation. These reflect evaluated project quality measured against the best remodeling firms in New York State.

PRO_Gold_Black_Horiz-1024x483

Gold

Residential Kitchen

$60,001-$100,000

PRO_Platinum_Black_Horiz-1024x483

Platinum

Residential Exterior

$100,001-$200,000

PRO_Platinum_Black_Horiz-1024x483

Platinum

Entire House

$750,001-$1,000,000

A Closer Look at Bellmore, NY

Bellmore combines a walkable downtown, established residential streets, postwar development, and waterfront neighborhoods. That range provides useful context for the different layouts and renovation goals found inside Bellmore homes.

Five Things to Know About Bellmore

  • The Bedell House

    The Bedell House on South Saint Mark's Place dates to approximately 1689 and is listed as a Town of Hempstead landmark. It represents a much earlier chapter of Bellmore's residential story than the suburban homes built during the twentieth century.

  • South Bellmore's Residential Canals

    Canals extending toward South Oyster Bay give southern Bellmore its waterfront character. The location does not determine the condition of an interior, but it can affect the broader property review for a substantial renovation.

  • Newbridge Road Park and the South Shore Blueway

    With pools, an ice rink, a dog park, and an accessible paddling launch, Newbridge Road Park serves as a major recreation destination within Bellmore. Its connection to the South Shore Blueway reflects the community's relationship with nearby waterways.

  • Downtown Bellmore and the Family Street Festival

    Bedford Avenue anchors Bellmore's downtown beside the elevated LIRR station. The annual Family Street Festival fills the area with vendors, food, and activities that bring residents into the commercial center.

  • Bellmore LIRR Station

    The Babylon Branch provides direct rail access between Bellmore and New York City. This transportation connection has helped Bellmore remain attractive to households that want suburban living with commuter access.

From its early residential history to its postwar growth and active downtown, Bellmore reflects several generations of Long Island living. Interior remodeling gives homeowners an opportunity to update the spaces behind those familiar exteriors while keeping the location, community connections, and neighborhood character they value.

bellmore-historical-image-gc-landing
gallery-kitchens-patchogue-2023-08

How Older Homes Influence Interior Remodeling Costs in Bellmore

Cost and timeline are the two concerns Bellmore homeowners raise most often, and both are tied directly to what's inside the walls.

  • Older homes frequently conceal outdated systems.

    Interior remodeling in an older home may reveal previous electrical, plumbing, insulation, framing, or finish work that was not visible before demolition.

  • Open layouts require structural permits.

    Load-bearing walls are common between the kitchen and living space in Bellmore's split-level and bi-level homes, and removing one requires an engineered plan and a Town of Hempstead permit.

  • Different home eras require different renovation strategies.

    A postwar North Bellmore Cape and a 1970s split-level in the same neighborhood can require entirely different structural approaches to achieve a similar open-concept result.

Evaluating each home individually, rather than assuming a template scope, is what keeps a project's cost estimate accurate before anything is written into the contract.

Serving Homeowners Across Bellmore and the South Shore

Center Island Contracting provides interior remodeling throughout Bellmore and North Bellmore, including layout reconfiguration, open-concept conversions, whole-home renovation, basement remodeling, and connected kitchen and living-space updates.

The interior of a Cape, ranch, split-level, or expanded home can change substantially over time. Center Island Contracting reviews the existing structure and systems so the new layout is based on what is actually present behind the finishes.

Dining Near Our Bellmore Projects

La Bella Cucina
Bellmore's La Bella Cucina pairs a family-run atmosphere with Italian-American cooking, house-made pasta, and a full cocktail menu.

Blue Waters Mediterranean Cuisine
Blue Waters in North Bellmore focuses on Greek and Mediterranean fare, with grilled fish, lamb, spreads, and familiar regional dishes.

Avenue Social Kitchen & Cocktails
Set along Bedford Avenue, Avenue Social is a downtown Bellmore option for contemporary American meals, craft cocktails, and Sunday brunch.

Bellmore-Aerial-View-gc-landing
bellmore-town-of-hempstead-gc-landing

WHAT TO EXPECT

Planning and Permitting for Interior Work in Bellmore

  • Town of Hempstead Department of Buildings

    Interior work involving structural changes or regulated electrical, plumbing, or HVAC work may require permits. Center Island Contracting confirms the requirements for the Bellmore home and final interior remodeling scope before construction.

  • Town of Hempstead Board of Appeals

    Interior-only remodeling rarely involves zoning relief, but an exterior expansion connected to the renovation may require review when setbacks or lot coverage are affected.

  • FEMA Flood Map Service Center

    Some canal-front and low-lying Bellmore properties fall within designated flood-hazard areas. Larger interior renovations should account for the property's current designation and any flood-related requirements that apply to the proposed work.

Play Video

Visit Our Design Studio & Showroom

Center Island Contracting maintains a private design center and showroom where you can review materials, finishes, and layouts in person with guidance from our team.
Seeing everything at full scale helps you make clearer decisions and avoid costly changes during construction.

By Appointment Only - Every visit is scheduled in advance to ensure focused, uninterrupted time with our design team.

hardwood-showroom-display

A RELIABLE PARTNER FROM START TO FINISH

What Makes Us the Right Choice for Your Renovation

Bellmore homeowners want clear scope, a reliable process, and results that match what was actually discussed at the start.

We define scope before construction begins

We manage permits in-house, handling submission and follow-up

We invite homeowners to select materials in our design studio showroom

Every scope modification is documented in writing

We handle the full project under one coordinated team

We guide layout and design decisions with clarity at every step

Common Interior Remodeling Challenges in Bellmore's Existing Homes

Most interior remodeling projects in Bellmore begin with layout limitations, not just outdated finishes.

Load-bearing walls blocking open-concept layouts in Bellmore's postwar Capes and ranches

Isolated kitchens and undersized primary suites standard in homes built before 1960

Outdated subfloors frequently uneven or deteriorated, requiring correction before new flooring goes down

Limited natural light in interior rooms that were designed as separate, closed-off spaces

HVAC ductwork conflicts resulting in unwanted soffits or reduced ceiling height in split-levels and bi-levels

Identifying these conditions before demolition begins is the purpose of Center Island Contracting's pre-construction process.

gallery-kitchens-syosset-2026-13
<span class="number-gallery">No. 5746</span><hr class="project-gallery-hr">SYOSSET INTERIOR RENOVATION

UNDERSTANDING THE NUMBERS

Understanding Interior Remodeling Costs in Bellmore

Interior remodeling costs in Bellmore are driven primarily by structural conditions and the systems hidden behind the walls.

Key cost factors:

  • Structural changes (wall removal, beams, layout shifts)

  • Age and condition of the home

  •  Electrical, plumbing, and HVAC upgrades

  • Project size and scope

  • Material and finish selections

During the Project Development Agreement (PDA), Center Island Contracting develops the detailed drawings, specifications, selections, scope, and pricing for the specific property.

Plan Your Project with Confidence

WHERE WE WORK IN YOUR HOME

Remodeling Services for Every Area of Your Home

Interior remodeling means working within existing structural walls, aging systems, and current code requirements, all at once.

Whole-Home Remodeling

Full interior reconfiguration across the entire living area, with finish replacement and system upgrades coordinated under a single phased plan. Center Island Contracting manages every phase from concept through completion with one point of accountability.

Primary Suite and Interior Expansions 

Reconfiguring bedroom layouts and expanding primary bathrooms within the existing footprint. Structural conditions are confirmed early so the final layout reflects what the home can actually support.

Basement and Bonus Room Renovation

Converting unfinished basements into livable, permitted space with moisture control and proper egress built into the plan from the start. Center Island Contracting scopes this work to Town of Hempstead code requirements before construction begins.

Living and Dining Room Reconfiguration

Opening up postwar floor plans through permitted structural work, including HVAC rerouting where required. A structural assessment is part of this scope given how common load-bearing walls are in Bellmore's ranch and split-level homes.

Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling

Full kitchen renovations covering layout, cabinetry, and systems, alongside bathroom remodels ranging from fixture updates to full gut renovations. Both are approached with the same attention to the home's existing structural conditions.

Interior Detailing and Finishes

Trim, built-ins, millwork, and flooring bring the renovation together as a cohesive finished space. Material selections are made in our showroom with guidance on performance and fit for the home.

gallery-new-construction-sag-harbor-2025-31

Working With Homeowners Across the South Shore

Center Island Contracting works with homeowners throughout Bellmore and neighboring South Shore communities across Nassau County.

A DEFINED PATH FROM START TO FINISH

A Step-by-Step Approach to Every Renovation

Every renovation follows the same structured sequence, with scope, cost, and timeline established before construction begins.

  • 1

    Consultation

    We visit your Bellmore home to assess existing conditions and understand your goals for the space.

  • 2

    Design Development and Planning

    Our in-house design team develops drawings and specifications based on your home's actual structural condition.

  • 3

    Permitting and Municipal Approvals

    We submit and manage the full permit application through the Town of Hempstead Department of Buildings, including any Board of Appeals variance if required.

  • 4

    Construction Phase

    Your renovation is built according to the fixed-price Project Development Agreement, with defined phases and regular updates.

  • 5

    Final Walkthrough and Project Closeout

    We complete a formal walkthrough and confirm all work meets the agreed specifications before closing out the project.

gallery-new-construction-sag-harbor-2025-30

Talk to Us About Your Project

Center Island Contracting helps homeowners throughout Bellmore plan interior renovations with clear scope, realistic pricing, and a process built around preparation rather than guesswork. The right time to start that conversation is before you've committed to a budget or a design. Reach out when you're ready to talk through what your home can support.

ABOUT INTERIOR REMODELING IN BELLMORE

Frequently Asked Questions